1 in 10 children in Syracuse, New York have been diagnosed with lead poisoning
a rate that remains alarmingly high despite years of awareness and intervention efforts. Lead exposure, even at low levels, can cause irreversible harm to brain development, learning ability, and behavior, with lifelong consequences. While deteriorating lead paint is the primary culprit, another factor often overlooked in public discussions is the presence of lead service lines delivering water to homes. The City of Syracuse has taken steps to address the issue, including mapping known lead pipes and committing to some replacements, but progress has been slow. Meanwhile, a clear overlap exists between neighborhoods with high rates of childhood lead poisoning and those with a high concentration of lead service lines. With lead exposure coming from multiple sources, the response must be comprehensive, prioritizing both housing safety and clean water access to protect the most vulnerable residents.
Understanding Lead Exposure in Syracuse
Lead Paint Dust
The Environmental Protection Agency confirms that deteriorating lead paint and the dust it creates is the most significant source of lead exposure in children (1). This dust accumulates from old paint (common in Syracuse's aging housing stock), contaminated soil, and renovation activities that disturb lead-based paint applied before its 1978 ban.
Children under six years old are especially vulnerable due to their frequent hand-to-mouth behaviors. Their developing bodies also absorb lead more readily than adults, and the damage to developing brains can be permanent and irreversible.
Lead in Water
Even though lead paint is the primary concern, lead in water still contributes significantly to overall exposure, especially in infants who consume formula mixed with tap water. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and EPA state unequivocally that no amount of lead exposure is safe for children, and multiple sources (paint, dust, soil, and water) add to a child's total lead burden (2).
The water crisis in Flint, Michigan, brought national attention to the dangers of lead-contaminated water. While Syracuse hasn't experienced a crisis of that magnitude, the presence of lead service lines throughout the city represents an ongoing risk factor that compounds other exposure sources.
What the Data Show
Syracuse tracks and publishes childhood lead poisoning data by neighborhood, allowing public health officials to identify hotspots where interventions are most urgently needed (3). The city has also created an interactive map of lead service lines to inform the public about potential water-related risks (4).
When these data sets are compared, a clear pattern emerges—many neighborhoods with high childhood lead poisoning rates also have a high concentration of lead service lines. This correlation suggests that addressing both issues simultaneously could yield better results than tackling them separately.
A visualization of the prevalence of lead water service lines compared to the rates of lead poisoning amongst children. ©East of Nowhere LLC. 2025.
The City's Efforts and Where Challenges Remain
Proactive Steps Syracuse Has Taken
The city has published an interactive map that allows residents to check if their home has a lead service line. This transparency is crucial for raising awareness and empowering residents to take protective measures.
There is also a commitment to replacing some lead service lines, and officials are actively working to secure funding for further efforts. The city has implemented lead testing programs as well, though challenges remain in execution.
Challenges That Need Attention
Botched Water Testing
A recent attempt to test household water for lead in Syracuse had flawed collection methods, leading to unreliable results (5). Some homes showed extremely high lead levels, but because the testing protocol wasn't followed correctly, the data was discarded, delaying necessary action.
This setback not only postponed potential interventions but also eroded public trust in testing programs, trust that will need to be rebuilt for future initiatives to succeed.
The Burden on Homeowners
Lead service lines are technically the homeowner's responsibility in most municipalities, including Syracuse. This places a significant financial burden on residents, many of whom live in economically disadvantaged areas where lead exposure risks are highest.
Most homeowners and tenants don't know what their service lines are made of or how to replace them. The cost (often thousands of dollars) is prohibitive for many Syracuse residents, especially in neighborhoods already struggling with economic challenges.
The Need for Faster Action
While the city is working on lead pipe replacements, progress is slow compared to the scale of the problem. Some high-risk areas may require a more targeted, urgent approach that prioritizes homes in neighborhoods with documented childhood lead poisoning cases.
Next Steps for a Stronger Response
Use the Data to Prioritize High-Risk Areas
The city should overlay lead poisoning and lead service line data to focus resources on the most vulnerable neighborhoods. This data-driven approach would ensure that limited funding has the maximum public health impact.
A targeted approach could ensure that the highest-risk homes, particularly those with young children or pregnant women, get lead service line replacements first, rather than addressing properties based solely on geographic convenience or homeowner requests.
Improve Public Awareness & Testing
While the interactive map is a valuable tool, more direct outreach is needed to inform residents about what they can do if their home has a lead pipe. This could include door-to-door information campaigns in high-risk neighborhoods, community meetings, and partnerships with healthcare providers who serve affected communities.
Water testing should be expanded and conducted with accurate collection methods to avoid another failed round of results.
Secure More Funding for Large-Scale Lead Service Line Replacement
While the city is making efforts, additional funding from state and federal programs could help accelerate lead pipe removal.
In high-risk areas, the city may need to take a more active role in replacing lead pipes rather than leaving it to individual homeowners. This could include subsidy programs, low-interest loans, or complete city funding for replacements in the highest-risk neighborhoods.
Continuing the Progress
Syracuse has taken steps to address lead exposure from multiple sources, but more can be done to connect lead service line data with public health efforts. Recognizing that lead exposure is cumulative, from paint, soil, and water, will help create a more effective response that addresses all potential sources.
Urgency is key when children's health is at stake. With better coordination of data and resources, Syracuse can take a leading role in addressing lead exposure comprehensively, potentially becoming a model for other cities facing similar challenges.
By connecting the dots between lead service lines and childhood lead poisoning data, Syracuse can ensure that its most vulnerable residents are protected, creating a healthier future for the next generation.
I appreciate you helping to shed light on this issue.